Economy
President Trump May 8, 2026 + (L inlay) Prime Minister Mark Carney Aug. 3, 2025 + (R inlay) Adjunct Assistant Professor Roy Norton Rawpixel.com + Harrison Ha | Shutterstock + @RoyNorton1 | X

Canadian diplomat says the Mark Carney should wait for Democrat-led U.S. congress to negotiate a trade deal — but some say tariffs may stay

Democrats are set to take control of both chambers of the U.S. Congress in January, and several want to roll back tariffs on Canada. That has raised a question in Ottawa: should Canada sign a trade deal with the Trump administration now, or wait to see what the new Congress can do?

Roy Norton, a former Canadian diplomat, says waiting is the smarter play, but two former ambassadors who testified before a House of Commons committee on Nov. 16 aren’t so sure.

Advertisement

How that debate shakes out could decide how long tariffs keep weighing on Canadian prices and jobs, at a time when high energy costs are already pushing up inflation and interest rates.

The best of Money.ca delivered weekly.

By signing up, you accept Money.ca Terms of Use, Subscription Agreement, and Privacy Policy.

Why does Roy Norton say Canada should hold off?

Norton’s diplomatic career included postings as consul general in Chicago and Detroit. Speaking with The Hill Times, he argued Prime Minister Mark Carney should wait to see whether the new Congress can eliminate tariffs through legislation before finalizing any agreement.

Norton said that striking a deal during this interim period that locks in a base tariff would be “unnecessary — maybe even foolish.” He argued that if lawmakers manage to roll back the tariffs, Canada would have no reason to accept a baseline tariff at all.

Norton believes affordability is now Washington’s top political concern, which gives Ottawa reason to slow-walk talks while lawmakers decide whether to act. In fact, representatives from Oregon, Massachusetts and Vermont have already publicly called for the tariffs on Canada to be repealed. (And Norton, among others, have pointed out that President Donald Trump’s trade war is “costing Republicans political support.”)

Some have argued that any deal struck now could be revisited at a later time, Norton rejects this idea. Revisiting it after the 2028 U.S. presidential election, he cautions, is risky as there’s no way to know if trade tariffs with Canada will be a dominant issue, or what trade policies the next president might pursue.

Must Read

Join 20,000+ readers and get Money.ca’s best stories and exclusive interviews first — clear insights curated and delivered weekly. Subscribe now.

Why do former ambassadors doubt Congress will deliver?

Not everyone with familiarity and expertise regarding U.S./Canada relations is confident that waiting is the best approach.

David Cohen served as U.S. ambassador to Canada under former president Joe Biden. Testifying before the House of Commons Standing Committee on Foreign Affairs and International Development, Cohen said he expects a deal soon but told MPs that Canadians shouldn’t count on the new Congress to reverse Trump’s tariffs.

Advertisement

Cohen noted how Carney was right to walk away from talks in August. More broadly, he praised how Ottawa has handled intense pressure from U.S. trade policy.

He’s less upbeat about Congress, though. Cohen doubts Democrats can win over enough Republicans to override a Trump veto on the president’s signature economic policy. He is also worried about “unrealistic optimism” among Canadians, after Democrats called ending the trade war a top priority once they take the majority in January.

There’s precedent for his caution. In April 2025, four Republicans joined Democrats as the Senate voted 51 to 48 to end the emergency declaration Trump used to justify his 2025 tariffs on Canada. The resolution never cleared the House, and the tariffs stayed in place.

David MacNaughton, Canada’s ambassador in Washington during Trump’s first term, said there may be no return to the relationship of that era. As a result, he argues that Canada should still seek a deal, while also diversifying trade and boosting productivity at home.

How much would a congressional rollback actually fix?

The Atlantic Council, a nonpartisan think tank based in Washington, modelled what a repeal could look like. The analysis found that scrapping the Section 338 tariffs would bring the average U.S. tariff on Canadian goods back down to a baseline of roughly 3%. U.S. businesses paid about US$385 million in duties on goods covered by those tariffs in September, up from US$33 million on the same products in July.

The Atlantic Council’s analysts also see enough bipartisan support in the new Congress to repeal Section 338 and override a Trump veto. That puts them directly at odds with Cohen.

But the analysis also shows how much would stay in place. The 10% Section 301 tariff on goods that don’t claim USMCA status would remain, as would Section 232 tariffs on steel, aluminum and trucks. Trump has also said tariffs on Canadian cars, trucks and auto parts will rise to 50% on Jan. 1, 2027.

Advertisement

Relief wouldn’t be immediate, either. A bill in Congress would refund tariffs already paid, but the Atlantic Council warns that with no clear timeline, businesses hit by the 50% tariffs “may shutter before the refunds arrive.”

What’s at stake for Canadians?

The Bank of Canada (BoC), the country’s central bank, raised its policy rate to 2.5% on Oct. 28, its first hike since July 2023, driven largely by higher gasoline and diesel prices. It also expects new U.S. tariffs to slow growth in the fourth quarter.

The BoC’s Business Outlook Survey, released Oct. 19, found new tariffs and counter-tariffs are pushing up firms’ costs, prices and inflation expectations, and roughly half of firms plan to pass at least some of those costs on to customers.

Statistics Canada, the federal statistics agency, reports inflation held at 3.1% in October; excluding energy, prices rose 2%.

Carney, for his part, isn’t counting on Congress. Speaking in Montreal on Nov. 10, he said the U.S. president and his administration, not lawmakers, will decide trade agreements for the next two or three years, and that tough issues remain unresolved. The next test comes quickly: the higher auto tariffs are due Jan. 1, days before the new Congress takes office.

Survey methodology

The Bank of Canada’s Business Outlook Survey was conducted through in-person, video and phone interviews with senior managers at about 100 firms from Aug. 6 to Sept. 2, 2026.

You May Also Like

The most expensive financial mistakes are often the ones you don't see coming. Join 19,000+ Canadians who get the money moves, risks and opportunities shaping their finances — delivered free each week. Subscribe now.

Share this:
David Saric Associate editor

Writer and editor based in Toronto with experience in personal finance, insurance, arts and culture and branded content.

more from David Saric

Explore the latest

Disclaimer

The content provided on Money.ca is information to help users become financially literate. It is neither tax nor legal advice, is not intended to be relied upon as a forecast, research or investment advice, and is not a recommendation, offer or solicitation to buy or sell any securities enter into any loan, mortgage or insurance agreements or to adopt any investment strategy. Tax, investment and all other decisions should be made, as appropriate, only with guidance from a qualified professional. We make no representation or warranty of any kind, either express or implied, with respect to the data provided, the timeliness thereof, the results to be obtained by the use thereof or any other matter. Advertisers are not responsible for the content of this site, including any editorials or reviews that may appear on this site. For complete and current information on any advertiser product, please visit their website.

†Terms and Conditions apply.